Questions? Call us: 1 (800) 851-7957   |   Shop Products   

Call us: 1 (800) 851-7957

Choosing Between Maca & Vitex? What You Need To Know

Choosing Between Maca & Vitex? What You Need To Know

I love getting clients started with fertility herbs! There are so many areas where herbs can support you when it comes to your fertility. Some herbs promote a stronger libido. Others encourage cervical mucus production. Herbs can aid in hormone balance, menstrual cycle issues, or even decrease problems like fibroids and endometriosis.

For us in the natural fertility world, Maca and Vitex are two of the biggest herbal superstars! We get asked about them the most. They are both endocrine system supporting herbs. Yet, they work slightly differently and have their own unique benefits.

The Mighty Maca

Fertilica Maca High Potency CapsLet’s begin with Maca (Lepedium meyenii). As an herbalist, this is one of my all-time favorite fertility herbs. While Maca has an effect on hormone balance, it’s a food-grade herb or a tonic. One thing that sets apart a tonic like Maca is that, as a food, it can be taken daily, long-term without ill effects or toxicity. Almost all of the women and the men I work with enhance their health on some level by taking Maca in Fertility Smoothies, extracts, or capsules daily.

I first became introduced to Maca for its natural mineral content, and ability to energize the adrenals and thyroid gland. In my experience, unlike Vitex, Maca is one herb people tend to feel the effects of within a few days to weeks of using it. It’s an energizer that is especially good for people who feel too tired or stressed for intercourse, exercise, or even normal life challenges.

Similar to Vitex, Maca nourishes the endocrine system and encourages normal pituitary gland function. PMS and menopausal symptoms often respond to Maca because it is believed to help balance the ratio of estrogen to progesterone. Maca plays an important role in male and female fertility, too. Animal research from 2004 published in the Journal of Endocrinology shows Maca can improve sperm count. Preliminary research with people also shows good results.

Tip: Maca works best in a specialized preparation. Look for “gelatinized” Maca root if you’re interested in trying it. “Gelatinized” simply means the starch has been removed to make Maca much easier to digest than the unprocessed root.

Vitex- Supreme Hormone Balancer

Fertilca VitexNow, let’s move on to Vitex (Vitex agnus castus). Vitex has been an herbal ally for women’s health for centuries. Also called Chastetree berry, Vitex’s medicine comes from the fruit. It’s one of the most popular herbs in Europe and Western countries for female hormone balance. In fact, for women with menstrual cycle problems, Vitex outshines most other herbs including Maca.

Today, Vitex is used to support healing from a long list of menstrual concerns: PMS mood swings, breast pain, acne and bloat, absent cycle, heavy or painful cycle, irregular cycle, anovulation and short cycles (common to perimenopause), etc.

Like Maca, Vitex has a regulating effect on the pituitary gland and is well known to aid women’s problems linked to low progesterone or imbalance between estrogen and progesterone. Agnuside in Vitex has mild hormone-mimicking activity and is believed to interact with hormone receptor sites in the body. While primarily used for women, men with high prolactin levels also benefit from using Vitex.

From an energetic perspective, Vitex is a spicy herb that helps break up stagnation in the uterus and ovaries. For this reason, it’s very helpful in natural programs for fibroids, ovarian cysts, and endometriosis.

Tip: Be aware that Vitex is a long-acting herb. It may take a few months or more to see results. In my view, using it as an extract, first thing in the morning before breakfast is the best choice.

Explore What Maca and Vitex Can Do for You

If you’re trying to decide between Vitex and Maca, consider what I’ve shared and do your own research. Explore what Maca and Vitex can do for you. Try to stay patient. Herbs take time to work, but with foundational nutritional support in place, the long-term results are well worth your effort.

I have found many women enhance their fertility health by using both herbs. If you try this route, do your best to be consistent. Both Maca and Vitex offer the most benefits when taken regularly for at least 3-6 months. We wish you well on your program and hope you come to love fertility herbs as much as we do!

Dr. Christine Traxler M.D., OB/GYN
Dr. Christine Traxler M.D., OB/GYN

Dr. Traxler is a University-trained obstetrician/gynecologist, working with patients in Minnesota for over 20 years. She is a professional medical writer; having authored multiple books on pregnancy and childbirth; textbooks and coursework for medical students and other healthcare providers; and has written over 1000 articles on medical, health, and wellness topics.  Dr. Traxler attended the University of Minnesota College of Biological Sciences and University of Minnesota Medical School,  earning a degree in biochemistry with summa cum laude honors in 1981,  and receiving her Medical Doctorate degree (MD) in 1986.

Related Articles


Let your voice be heard... Leave a brief comment or question related to this article.

 characters available
  1. Avatar

    Hi Elizabeth,

    I’m 43 and my blood tests show I’m in perimenopause. I haven’t had a period in 3 months. My mom was 51 when she completed menopause, so I’m early and I believe it is due to an intense period of stress. I was having hot flashes, but those have stopped with taking 1-2 tbsp. of ground flax seed a day. My blood test shows testosterone=32 (normal range – on high end); progesterone= .3; estradiol=<5.0 (very very low); FSH =154.9 (extremely high). Since I'm starting menopause due to stress, is it possible to delay it? What herbs would you recommend and in what dosages? Thank you!

    • Dear Michelle,

      Stress can indeed be that impactful. I am sorry you have had to go through this and hope that you now have many tools to help you when it rears its ugly head!

      Tests revealing pre-/perimenopausal hormone levels in your 30s or 40s indicate hormonal imbalance. Chances of conception haven’t ended. There simply is work to be done! We share details in our guide Female Fertility Health: Balancing Hormones in Premenopause.

      I hope had guide give you hope and many ideas of what you can do to support a return to balance knowing that cycles can shift as we travel through out 40s and that is completely normal.

    • Avatar

      Dear Elizabeth,

      Thank you for your response. What I’m looking for is what herbals I should be taking at this time. What would you recommend, specifically and in what doses? I’m not looking to get pregnant (we have a 7 year old), I just don’t want to start menopause this early as I’ve read there are some serious health and other problems related to early menopause. I also have high reverse T3 and hydrogen dominant SIBO. Thank you!

    • Sure Michelle and that is fine! Our guides speak to wanting to conceive because we focus on preconception health, but one does not have to want to conceive to follow our advice. The guide I shared still applies.

      For suggestions on what exactly to take and how much, we would suggest participating in a Fertility Consultation. Learn more about the Fertility Consultation experience and book one here…

  2. Avatar

    can you take both herbs together and what times. Is it effective when going through menopause?

    • Dear AnnieV,

      While Vitex and Maca can be taken together, I can not know their effectiveness if one is truly in menopause. For some women Vitex may be helpful in maintaining regular cycles and lowering higher FSH levels, but Vitex cannot reverse the aging process. It may or may not be effective for women in perimenopause; each woman is different. Vitex cannot bring back the menstrual cycle in women who have gone through menopause.